Myrtle's Main Menu

Side of Meatballs

3 Meatballs, Sauce and Parmesan Cheese

Side of Grilled Chicken

Juicy chicken pan seared in EVOO, topped with salt, pepper, mozzarella cheese and parsley. 1 breast.

Pizza Pinwheel

Choice of Spinach & Broccoli, Pepperoni or Stromboli (smoked cheddar, pepperoni, sweet salami, Italian sausage and everything seasoning crust)

Pesto Garlic Bread

12" hero bread smothered with our gourmet buttery pesto and garlic spread.

Garlic Bread

12" hero bread smothered with our gourmet buttery garlic spread.

Beef Patty

Magic Patty

Packed with mozzarella, pepperoni, lettuce and tomato

Mac Patty

Pepperoni, Mozzarella, Pickles & Hot sauce

Buffalo Knots

Tossed in buffalo Sauce, drizzled with ranch dressing, sprinkled with parsley, diced pickle and Parmesan cheese. 3 Knots

Garlic Knots

Marinated in rich oil and minced garlic, topped with parsley and fresh Parmesan cheese. 3 Knots

★ Create Your Own Salad

If you can imagine it, we can toss it! Mix and match to make your own tasty salad. Served on an 8" aluminum pan with includes 3 garlic knots and a side of marinara sauce.

Burrata Salad

Baby arugula, creamy burrata, sliced tomatoes, fresh basil.

Chicken Caprese Salad

Fried Chicken Cutlet topped with baby arugula, cherry tomatoes, onion , basil, fresh mozzarella and EVOO.

Greek Salad

Crispy romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, sliced red onions, cucumbers, feta cheese, kalamata olives, oregano and EVOO

Insalata Mista

Crispy romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, chickpeas, red onions, Kalamata olives, oregano.

Antipasto Salad

Chopped and mixed with salami, pepperoni, kalamata olives, marinated artichokes, peppers and cherry tomatoes; Topped with grated cheese.

Chicken Caesar Salad

Juicy grilled chicken, on a bed of crispy romaine lettuce and croutons, topped with creamy Caesar dressing and grated cheese.

Grilled Chicken Salad

Savory grilled chicken breast on a bed of crispy romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, red onions, Kalamata olives and oregano. Add extras as desired.

Caprese Salad

Mozzarella Fior di Latte, Sliced Tomatoes, fresh basil, salt, pepper and oregano.

Caesar Salad

Crispy romaine lettuce & croutons tossed in Creamy Caesar Dressing; Topped with grated cheese.

House Salad

Crispy Romaine Lettuce, Juicy Tomatoes , Red Onions, and Black Olives.

Lasagna

Home made lasagna stuffed with ricotta cheese, ground beef, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese.

Pasta Alfredo Sauce

Homemade creamy Alfredo Sauce, topped with parsley and parmesan cheese. Choice of Fettuccine, Spaghetti or Penne.

Stuffed Shells

Home made shells stuffed with ricotta cheese, tomato sauce and Parmesan cheese.

Spaghetti Meatballs

Spaghetti and Meatballs in tomato sauce

Pasta Vodka Sauce

Tossed in rich and delicious tomato-vodka and cream sauce, topped with grated cheese and fresh basil. Choice of Penne, Spaghetti or Fettuccine.

Pasta Pesto Sauce

Tossed in thick, homemade, fresh basil pesto sauce, topped with grated cheese and fresh basil. Choice of Penne, Spaghetti or Fettuccine

Pasta Marinara Sauce

Rich marinara sauce, basil and EVOO. Choice of Penne, Spaghetti or Fettuccine

Pasta Broccoli And Parmesan

Ziti baked with sauted broccoli, topped with parmesan and mozzarella cheese.

Baked Ziti

Oven baked Ziti tossed with ricotta, tomato sauce; Topped with extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil, and Parmesan cheese; Includes 3 garlic knots.

Pasta With Butter Sauce

Simple; for kids. Pasta sauteed in butter.

Chicken Parm Entree

Choice of Pasta or Side of Salad. Includes homemade focaccia bread.

Eggplant Parm Entree

Choice of Pasta or Side of Salad. Includes homemade focaccia bread.

Meatball Parm Entree

Choice of Pasta or Side of Salad. Includes homemade focaccia bread.

Sausage Parm Entree

Choice of Pasta or Side of Salad. Includes homemade focaccia bread.

Sausage & Peppers Parm Entree

Choice of Pasta or Side of Salad. Includes homemade focaccia bread.

Vodka Chicken Parm Entree

Choice of Pasta or Side of Salad. Includes homemade focaccia bread.

★ Create Your Own Pie (Large)

If you can imagine it, we can make it. Mix and match from select specialty pies and, optionally, add toppings to your satisfaction. Go ahead, get creative. PROTIP: This section is for creative specialty half and half pies. If you are looking to order a regular cheese pie with a few toppings, head on over to the 'Cheese Pizza' menu item; NB: Pies marked with an * can only be prepared on 12x17x1 Thick Crust.

Deep Dish Pizza

A Deep Dish twist to our specialty pies. Choice of crust seasoning. 3" thick by 16" round; cut into 6 Slices.

Cheese Pizza (12" Personal)

Sauce and mozzarella cheese. Add desired toppings; (12", cut into 6 slices);

Cheese Pizza (18" Large)

Sauce and mozzarella cheese. Choose desired toppings; 18" Round, 8 slices

Pepperoni Pizza (12" Personal)

Sauce, mozzarella cheese and savory pepperoni. Add extra toppings as desired; (12", cut into 6 slices);

Pepperoni Pizza (18" Large)

Sauce, mozzarella cheese and savory Pepperoni. Add extra toppings as desired; 18" Round, 8 slices

Siciliana Pizza (12" Square)

Thick, fluffy, and juicy. That's how we like our Sicilians. Savory tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, topped with fresh parmesan cheese. 12" x 12" thick crust, Cut into 6 square slices.

Siciliana Pizza (16" Large)

Thick, fluffy, and juicy. That's how we like our Sicilians. Savory tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, topped with fresh parmesan cheese (16" x 16" - Cut into 12 Slices)

Nonna Pizza (12" Square)

Grandma's old recipe. Travel back to the days when nonna baked that wholesome gourmet pizza right in your kitchen. This thick crust delicacy is packed with savory marinara sauce, roasted garlic, fresh mozzarella cheese, Grana Padano, fresh basil, and extra virgin olive oil. 12" x 12" thick crust, Cut into 6 square slices.

Nonna Pizza (17" Large)

Grandma's old recipe. Travel back to the days when nonna baked that wholesome gourmet pizza right in your kitchen. This deep-dish delicacy is packed with savory marinara sauce, roasted garlic, fresh mozzarella cheese, Grana Padano, fresh basil, and extra virgin olive oil. 12" x 17" thick crust, Cut into 8 square slices.

★ Nonno Pizza (12" Square)

Grampa's wicked good recipe. Marinara sauce, crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, homemade pesto sauce, fresh garlic and sesame crust. 12" x 12" thick crust, Cut into 6 square slices.

Nonno Pizza (16" Large)

Grampa's wicked good recipe. Marinara sauce, crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, homemade pesto sauce and fresh garlic. 16"×16", cut in 12 squares

Sweet & Spicy Pepperoni Burrata Pizza (12" Personal)

This masterpiece starts with a rich tomato sauce and melted mozzarella, layered with savory pepperoni and crowned with luscious, creamy burrata. Finished with a drizzle of our homemade hot honey, fresh basil, a sprinkle of parmesan, and a touch of extra virgin olive oil for the ultimate sweet, spicy, and savory bite. 12" Round, 6 slices.

Sweet & Spicy Pepperoni Burrata Pizza (18" Large)

This masterpiece starts with a rich tomato sauce and melted mozzarella, layered with savory pepperoni and crowned with luscious, creamy burrata. Finished with a drizzle of our homemade hot honey, fresh basil, a sprinkle of parmesan, and a touch of extra virgin olive oil for the ultimate sweet, spicy, and savory bite.

★ Truffle Mushroom (12" Personal)

Creamy mushroom sauce, Truffle oil, and Burrata; Topped with fresh mushrooms, basil and parmesan; (12", cut into 6 slices);

Truffle Mushroom (Large 18")

Creamy mushroom sauce, Truffle oil, and Burrata; Topped with fresh mushrooms, basil and parmesan;

White Ricotta (12" Personal)

Inspired by the popular "quattro formaggi" this beauty is layered in mozzarella cheese, creamy ricotta, sharp provolone and smoked mozzarella (12", cut into 6 slices);

White Ricotta (18" Large)

Inspired by the popular "quattro formaggi" this beauty is layered in mozzarella cheese, creamy ricotta, sharp provolone and smoked mozzarella (18" round, cut into 8 slices);

Fire & Ice Pizza (12" Personal)

This fiery twist on our White Ricotta Pie is layered with mozzarella, creamy ricotta, sharp provolone, and smoked mozzarella, then topped with savory pepperoni for a smoky, meaty kick. A drizzle of homemade hot honey brings the perfect balance of sweet heat, while a final sprinkle of Parmesan cheese ties it all together.

Fire & Ice Pizza (18" Large)

This fiery twist on our White Ricotta Pie is layered with mozzarella, creamy ricotta, sharp provolone, and smoked mozzarella, then topped with savory pepperoni for a smoky, meaty kick. A drizzle of homemade hot honey brings the perfect balance of sweet heat, while a final sprinkle of Parmesan cheese ties it all together.

★ Ricotta e Mortadella Pizza (12" Personal)

This masterpiece starts with a spicy basil-pistachio infused ricotta, layered over a bed of fresh arugula and creamy mozzarella cheese. Delicately folded mortadella adds a rich, velvety touch, while a crunchy pistachio crumble brings a satisfying contrast. Finished with a drizzle of our homemade sweet & spicy honey, this pizza is an irresistible balance of savory, nutty, and subtly sweet flavors

★ Ricotta e Mortadella Pizza (18" Large)

This masterpiece starts with a spicy basil-pistachio infused ricotta, layered over a bed of fresh arugula and creamy mozzarella cheese. Delicately folded mortadella adds a rich, velvety touch, while a crunchy pistachio crumble brings a satisfying contrast. Finished with a drizzle of our homemade sweet & spicy honey, this pizza is an irresistible balance of savory, nutty, and subtly sweet flavors

Margherita Pizza (12" Personal)

Topped with Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Cherry Tomatoes; Drizzled with Extra Virgin Olive Oil and sprinkled with fresh Parmesan cheese, (12", cut into 6 slices);

Margherita Pizza (18" Large)

Topped with Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Cherry Tomatoes; Drizzled with Extra Virgin Olive Oil and sprinkled with fresh Parmesan cheese; 18" Round, 8 slices

Roasted Zucchini Pizza (12" Personal)

No sauce. Roasted zucchini on a bed of mozzarella cheese, smoked mozzarella, topped with basil, mascarpone, Parmesan and EVOO. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Roasted Zucchini Pizza (18" Large)

No sauce. Roasted zucchini on a bed of mozzarella cheese, smoked mozzarella, topped with basil, mascarpone, Parmesan and EVOO. 18" Round, 8 slices

Cream O' Spinach Pizza (12" Personal)

Smooth, homemade cream of spinach, topped with fresh mozzarella, garlic & olive oil sautéed spinach, cherry tomatoes, a touch of mascarpone, dressed with fresh parmesan, basil and EVOO. No Tomato Sauce, (12", cut into 6 slices);

Cream O' Spinach Pizza (18" Large)

Smooth, homemade cream of spinach, topped with fresh mozzarella, garlic & olive oil sautéed spinach, cherry tomatoes, a touch of mascarpone, dressed with fresh parmesan, basil and EVOO. No Tomato Sauce, 18" Round, 8 slices

La Burrata Pizza (12" Personal)

Sauce, mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, topped with fresh burrata, basil, Parmesan and EVOO. (12", cut into 6 slices);

La Burrata Pizza (18' Large)

Sauce, mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, topped with fresh burrata, basil, Parmesan and EVOO. 18" Round, 8 slices

Pesto Burrata Pizza (12" Personal)

You can't go wrong with this founder's favorite. Mozzarella cheese and homemade basil pesto. Dressed with fresh basil leaves, Parmesan cheese, olive oil, and topped with le piece de resistance. Fresh burrata. 12" x 12" thick crust, Cut into 6 square slices.

Pesto Burrata Pizza (12" x 17" Large)

You can't go wrong with this founder's favorite. Mozzarella cheese and homemade basil pesto. Dressed with fresh basil leaves, Parmesan cheese, olive oil, and topped with le piece de resistance. Fresh burrata. 12" x 17" thick crust, Cut into 8 square slices.

Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (12" Personal)

No sauce, mozzarella, sliced onions, roasted green peppers, smoked cheddar and a juicy, delicious philly steak. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (18" Large)

No sauce, mozzarella, sliced onions, roasted green peppers, smoked cheddar and a juicy, delicious philly steak.

Burrata Pomodoro Pizza (12" Square)

Savory sauce, mozzarella cheese, creamy burrata arugula and tomatoes. Topped with fresh basil and EVOO. 12" x 12" , Cut into 6 square slices.

Burrata Pomodoro Pizza (12" x 17" Large)

Savory sauce, mozzarella cheese, creamy burrata arugula and tomatoes. Topped with fresh basil and EVOO ; 12" x 17" thick crust, Cut into 8 square slices.

Giardiniera Pizza (12" Personal)

No Sauce. Mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, mushrooms, broccoli, olives and onions, topped with fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Giardiniera Pizza (18" Large)

No Sauce. Mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, mushrooms, broccoli, olives and onions, topped with fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil. 18" Round, 8 slices

Vodka Pizza (12" Personal)

Vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, fresh basil and EVOO. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Vodka Pizza (18" Large)

Vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, fresh basil and EVOO. 18" Round, 8 slices

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (12" Personal)

No sauce, mozzarella, savory chicken cutlet, topped with bacon brittle and ranch dressing. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (18" Large)

No sauce, mozzarella, savory chicken cutlet, topped with bacon brittle and ranch dressing. 18" Round, 8 slices

Buffalo Chicken Pizza (12" Personal)

No sauce, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken marinated in traditional buffalo sauce, drizzled with blue cheese dressing and topped with diced jalapeno and red onion. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Buffalo Chicken Pizza (18" Large)

No sauce, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken marinated in traditional buffalo sauce, drizzled with blue cheese dressing and topped with diced jalapeno and red onion. 18" Round, 8 slices

Crown Chicken Pizza (12" Personal)

Buffalo chicken meets BBQ chicken to deliver a mouth-watering, flavor-packing, and jalapeno-popping pizza. Savory sauce, mozzarella & cheddar cheese, chicken marinated in our special BBQ Buffalo sauce, sprinkled with diced jalapenos and red onions. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Crown Chicken Pizza (18" Large)

Buffalo chicken meets BBQ chicken to deliver a mouth-watering, flavor-packing, and jalapeno-popping pizza. Savory sauce, mozzarella & cheddar cheese, chicken marinated in our special BBQ Buffalo sauce, sprinkled with diced jalapenos and red onions. 18" Round, 8 slices

Meat Lovers Pizza (12" Personal)

This hearty classic is packed with rich, meaty goodness. We start with savory sauce and a generous layer of mozzarella cheese. Then, we pile on the best of the best—juicy Italian sausage, tender homemade meatballs, crispy bacon, and zesty pepperoni.

Meat Lovers Pizza (18" Large)

This hearty classic is packed with rich, meaty goodness. We start with savory sauce and a generous layer of mozzarella cheese. Then, we pile on the best of the best—juicy Italian sausage, tender homemade meatballs, crispy bacon, and zesty pepperoni.

Salumi Pizza (12" Square)

Make it piccante. Sauce, mozzarella, spicy salami, topped with homemade hot chili oil. 12" x 12" thick crust, Cut into 6 square slices.

Salumi Pizza (12" x 17" Large)

Make it piccante. Sauce, mozzarella, spicy salami, sesame crust, topped with homemade hot chili oil. 12" x 17" thick crust, Cut into 8 square slices.

Arugula Pizza (12" Personal)

No sauce, mozzarella cheese, baby arugula, fresh Parmesan cheese, and white truffle oil. Choice of Marinated Artichokes and Kalamata Olives or Roasted Cherry Tomatoes & Parmigiano. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Arugula Pizza (18" Large)

No sauce, mozzarella cheese, baby arugula, fresh Parmesan cheese, and white truffle oil. Choice of Marinated Artichokes and Kalamata Olives or Roasted Cherry Tomatoes & Parmigiano. 18" Round, 8 Slices; TIP: Want the best of both worlds? Head on over to the 'Create Your Own Pie' menu item and get one half artichokes & olives and the other half cherry tomatoes.

Bianca Pizza (12" Personal)

Mozzarella, dressed with white caramelized onions, sprinkled with Gorgonzola cheese and topped with EVOO; No sauce; (12", cut into 6 slices);

Bianca Pizza (18" Large)

Mozzarella, dressed with white caramelized onions, sprinkled with Gorgonzola cheese and topped with EVOO; No sauce; 18" Round, 8 Slices

Little Louie's Pizza (12" Personal)

We're bringing zesty back! Sprinkled with bacon brittle, tomato & blue cheese, this old time favorite never ceases to deliver. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Little Louie's Pizza (18" Large)

We're bringing zesty back! Sprinkled with bacon brittle, tomato & blue cheese, this old time favorite never ceases to deliver. 18" Round, 8 Slices

Randazzo Pizza (12" Personal)

Made with savory sauce, mozzarella cheese, cherry tomatoes, and oven-baked diced & spicy eggplant. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Randazzo Pizza (18" Large)

Made with savory sauce, mozzarella cheese, cherry tomatoes, and oven-baked diced & spicy eggplant. 18" Round, 8 Slices

Vegan Marinara Pizza (12" Personal)

No cheese. Spicy Tomato sauce / Fresh cherry tomato , Roasted Garlic , Fresh Basil EVO 12", (12", cut into 6 slices);

Vegan Marinara Pizza (18" Large)

No cheese. Spicy Tomato sauce / Fresh cherry tomato , Roasted Garlic , Fresh Basil EVO. 18" Round, 8 Slices

Romana Pizza (12" Personal)

Sauce, mozzarella & peperoni; Topped with Gorgonzola Cheese and Baby Arugula. (12", cut into 6 slices);

Romana Pizza (18" Large)

Sauce, mozzarella & peperoni; Topped with Gorgonzola Cheese and Baby Arugula. 18" Round, 8 Slices

Cheese Slice

Savory Sauce And Cheese Slice - possibly the biggest you'll find in Brooklyn.

Sicilian Slice

Square, Thick, Fluffy and Juicy. That's how we like our Sicilians.

Pepperoni Slice

Cheese slice with savory cup-n-char pepperoni.

Nonna Slice

Grandma's old recipe. This thick crust delicacy is packed with tangy marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil, square slice.

Pesto Burrata Slice

You can't go wrong with this founder's favorite. Made with Mozzarella Cheese, Homemade Basil Pesto; Dressed with Fresh Basil leaves, Parmesan Cheese, Olive Oil and topped with Le Pièce De Résistance... Fresh Burrata; Square.

Buffalo Chicken Slice

Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

SPICY PEPPERONI

Philly Cheesesteak Slice

Chicken Parmesan Hero

Served on a 10" hero bread.

Meatball Parmesan Hero

Served on a 10" hero bread.

Chicken Parm Sandwich

Savory chicken parmesan with mozzarella cheese in a home-made sandwich roll glazed with extra virgin olive oil, sprinkled with fresh garlic and parsley.

JoJo's Crispy Chicken Sandwich

Chicken Cutlet topped with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and garlic lime mayo; Served on a potato bun.

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Chicken Cutlet smothered in spicy buffalo sauce, topped with red onions, pickles, and ranch dressing; Served on a potato bun.

Sausage & Peppers Parm Hero

Served on a 10" hero bread.

Philly Cheesesteak Hero

Juicy and delicious Philly Steak, sliced onions, roasted green peppers. Choice of smoked cheddar or fresh mozzarella. Served on a 10" hero bread.

Buffalo Chicken Hero

Savory buffalo chicken, with lettuce and tomato and blue cheese dressing.

Eggplant Parm Hero

Served on a 10" hero bread.

Sausage Parm Hero

Served on a 10" hero bread.

Grilled Chicken Hero

With spinach and fresh mozzarella

Chicken Roll

Sauce, cheese and chicken cutlet.

Buffalo Chicken Roll

Chicken cutlet marinated in buffalo sauce, packed with mozzarella cheese

Pepperoni Roll

Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese.

Spinach Roll

Spinach, mozzarella cheese, and fresh ricotta.

Eggplant Roll

Veggie Roll

Cheese, peppers, onions, broccoli, and olives.

Sausage and Peppers Roll

Cheese, Italian sausage, and tasty peppers.

Cheese Calzone

Traditional calzone with cheese and ricotta. Add-ons at will.

Mini Cannolis

Crunchy cannoli shell, rich cannoli cream, powdered sugar.

Cookie Butter Banana Cheesecake

Cookie butter crumb crust, layered with naturally banana -flavored cheesecake, banana chunks, topped with a velvety cookie butter mousse and vanilla whipped cream.

Sweet Potato Maple Cheesecake

Your taste buds wont know what season it is... Relish in this premium Sweet Potato Maple cheesecake made with a blend of cream cheese, sour cream and cinnamon layered on a graham cracker crust.

Strawberry Cheesecake

A smooth cream cheese & strawberry filling symphony, nestled in a graham cracker crust and topped with a strawberry filling glaze.

Tiramisu

silky smooth mascarpone cream, espresso soused savoiardi, dusted with dutch cocoa.

Beer & Wine (Must Be 21 to Order)

Aint nuttin better than a chilled beer or sparkling wine to go with your delicious slices; Cans: Beer 12oz / Wine 250ml.

Mike's Hard Beverages (Must be 21 to Order)

Hard n Crisp, Mike's Premium malt beverage.

Boylan Soda

Boylan Soda; Choose a flavor. 12oz bottle

Arizona Beverages

Refreshing, thirst quenching drinks.

Snapple

16oz bottle

Soda Can

12 oz can

2LT Bottle Of Soda

Water Bottle

16 oz bottle

Juices

10oz bottle.

Spicey Honey (4oz)

Joe and Sal's home made Sweet & Spicy Honey. This delicious delicacy can dress (almost) anything. Drizzle over pizza, dunk-in some knots or zeppoles, and brace for the wholesome goodness. 4oz cup

Ranch Dressing

4oz cup

Jalapeno Ranch Dressing

Home made with roasted Jalapenos, garlic and onion. 4oz cup

Caesar Dressing

Creamy Caesar Dressing 4oz cup

Blue Cheese Dressing

Blue Cheese Dressing 4oz cup

Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing

4oz cup

Oil & Vinegar

Oil and Vinegar Mix 4oz cup

Marinara Sauce

Tangy 4oz cup

Tomato Sauce

Zesty 4oz cup

Buffalo Sauce

Spicy Homemade Buffalo Sauce 4oz cup

Parmesan Cheese

Fresh grated parmesan cheese 4oz cup

Bacon Bits

A side of bacon bits 4oz cup